NDESPA logo

NDESPA logo
NDESPA
Showing posts with label Consumer Protections. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Consumer Protections. Show all posts

Tuesday, September 5, 2017

From HuffPost: CFPB Rule Fight Forces Senators to Choose: Military Families or Big Banks

09/04/2017 09:46 am ET

When Gary Childress of Raleigh, North Carolina learned in July 2008 that he was being deployed to Iraq as part of his Army National Guard service, one of the things he did before reporting for duty was to contact Bank of America, where he and his wife Anne had a credit card account. He wanted to let the bank know that he was on active-duty status because under the Servicemembers Civil Relief Act or SCRA, a law passed by Congress in 2003 to reduce burdens on military families, all interest rates on debts that servicemembers owed before going on active status must be reduced to 6%. This interest rate protection was significant to the Childresses, who owed over $5000 on their Bank of America credit card with an interest rate of around 27% when Gary left for Iraq.
Bank of America began sending Anne Childress monthly statements suggesting that the interest rate on the account had been reduced to 6% as the SCRA requires. But according to a lawsuit the bankjust settled in federal court in North Carolina, these statements were deceptive. In fact, the bank was actually continuing to charge a much higher interest rate. And the Childresses were not alone; the bank’s own internal audits, as well as an investigation conducted by the Office Of the Comptroller of the Currency, revealed that nearly 130,000 servicemembers and their families were affected by Bank of America’s illegal and deceptive practices, which went on for over a decade.
One of the other families affected was Jackie and Raymond Love of Garrett, Indiana, who had a mortgage with Bank of America with an interest rate of 7% when Raymond was deployed to Iraq in 2004. Like the Childresses, the Loves asked Bank of America to reduce their monthly payments to 6% in accordance with the SCRA, and Bank of America began issuing monthly statements suggesting that it had complied, but later investigations showed that the Loves’ mortgage rate was not in fact reduced. What’s worse, the formula Bank of America used to make it appear that the Loves’ rate had been reduced to 6%, known as interest subsidization, caused the Loves’ mortgage payments to be recorded as late even when they paid on time, which in turn damaged their credit score. The Loves filed for bankruptcy in 2011, and their house was sold at auction.
In 2015, the Childresses and others fiiled a class action lawsuit. And in July of 2017, they reached a settlement with Bank of America that will award nearly $30 million, after fees and expenses, to the approximately 130,000 military families who were overcharged and deceived by the bank. The cheated servicemembers will not need to file claims in order to receive compensation under the settlement; the amount owed to each class member will be calculated based on Bank of America’s records, and checks will be sent out automatically. If any class members can’t be found or their checks go uncashed, the remaining funds will be donated to nonprofits that provide assistance to servicemebers and veterans.
This class action lawsuit was possible because Bank of America does not force its credit card customers to enter into arbitration provisions that ban class actions. But most banks do. In fact, in a comprehensive report to Congress in 2015, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) found that over half of credit card contracts include provisions requiring customers to settle disputes in private arbitration rather than in court, and nearly all of those provisions ban class actions. Moreover, the CFPB’s study found that large banks were far more likely than small banks and credit unions to include forced arbitration provisions and class action bans in their account agreements. The CFPB study found that where bank arbitration clauses ban class actions, only an infinitesimal number of consumers ever go to arbitration; more than 99.9% of cases just disappear and no consumers receive anything.
So, if another large bank systematically overcharged servicemembers interest in violation of the SCRA and lied about it like Bank of America did, those affected would not have been able to join together in a class action lawsuit like the Childresses and Loves. Instead, they would each be forced to go up against the bank by themselves in a secretive arbitration proceeding, where confidentiality rules would prevent each servicemember from sharing information with others. Given the many demands on military families’ time, most people affected by such a scheme would never even find out that their rights had been violated, let alone pursue in arbitration the money they were owed. And instead of paying nearly $30 million to around 130,000 military families as Bank of America did, a bank with an arbitration provision banning class actions would have paid nothing, or at most might only have to pay out a few thousand dollars to a handful of servicemembers if any went forward with arbitration.
Now, the Senate will soon be asked to decide whether it is better if Americans can enforce consumer protection laws, as the servicemembers in these cases did, or if it’s better to let banks pocket millions of dollars in illegal profits at the expense of those who defend our nation.
That’s because, on July 19, 2017, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau issued its long-awaited rule that prohibits banks and payday lenders from using forced arbitration clauses to strip consumers of their ability to bring class actions against them. If that rule is permitted to go into effect, all military families, and all American consumers, will be able to join together in a class action lawsuit like the Childresses and others did if they were harmed by widespread illegal conduct in the financial sector, no matter who their lender happens to be. Unfortunately, on July 25, the U.S. House of Representatives voted to repeal the CFPB’s rule under the Congressional Review Act, a law that allows Congress to throw out any federal regulation issued within the last sixty days. Big banks want the Senate to follow suit, and pundits suggest that the vote will be close.
So, it’s time for Senators to decide whose side they’re on: big Wall street banks who don’t want consumers to be able to hold them accountable in court for their actions, or military families and other everyday Americans who want to be able to join forces and fight back when banks rip them off. America is watching.
This post was co-authored by Karla Gilbride, Cartwright-Baron Staff Attorney at Public Justice


Thursday, August 10, 2017

From Americans for Financial Reform: Payday Lenders Have a Pal at the White House

During a recent appearance on “Meet the Press,” unofficial Trump advisor Corey Lewandowski called for the removal of Richard Cordray as director of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.
His statement seemed to come out of nowhere, prompting NBC’s Chuck Todd to seek an explanation: Did Lewandowski happen to have “a client that wants” Cordray fired?
“No, no,” he insisted, “I have no clients whatsoever.”
That emphatic denial stood unchallenged for two days — until the New York Times revealed Lewandowski’s ties to Community Choice Financial, an Ohio-based company that was a major client of his former consulting firm before offering his new firm a $20,000-a-month retainer for “strategic advice and counsel.”
Community Choice is one of the country’s biggest players in the world of triple-digit-interest payday and car-title loans. Majority-owned by Diamond Castle Holdings, a private equity firm with $9 billion in assets, the company has more than 500 storefronts and does business (factoring in its online as well as physical operations) in 29 states.
The company’s CEO has described the Consumer Bureau as “the great Darth Vader” of the federal government, and the source of that ill-feeling is plain to see.
The Consumer Bureau is getting ready to issue a set of consumer-lending rules that, if they resemble a proposal put forward last year, will require verification of a borrower’s ability to repay. That simple concept runs directly counter to the business model of the payday industry, which is to keep its customers in debt indefinitely, making payments that put little or no dent in the principal. Many people end up spending more in loan charges than they borrowed in the first place.
Like other payday lenders, Community Choice Financial has been a magnet for complaints and investigations. A California class-action lawsuit filed last year accuses the company, along with its subsidiary Buckeye CheckSmart, of violating a federal telephone-harassment law. That is also the theme of dozens of stories submitted to the Consumer Bureau’s complaint database. “This company,” says one borrower, “called my elderly parents issuing threats against me to ‘subpoena’ me to court…”
Another complainant describes a series of phone calls and “threats of criminal prosecution… on a loan I know nothing about, did not apply for or receive, and have never received any bills for.” Community Choice and its subsidiaries — companies with names like Easy Money, Cash & Go, and Quick Cash — figure in more than 650 Consumer Bureau complaints, over unexpected fees, uncredited payments, bank overdraft charges triggered by oddly-timed electronic debits, and collection efforts that continue even after a debt has been fully repaid, among other recurring issues.
Community Choice has also been a pioneer in in the subspecialty of evading state interest-rate caps. In Ohio and Texas, among other states that have tried to ban payday loans, Community Choice’s payday shops have camouflaged their predatory loans by using bank-issued prepaid cards with credit lines and overdraft charges; calling themselves mortgage lenders instead of consumer lenders; and registering as credit repair companies in order to charge separately for their supposed assistance in resolving people’s financial troubles.
The success of these legal workarounds tells us that it will be very hard for the states to address the scourge of payday lending without help. That’s why payday lenders are pushing Congress to strip the Consumer Bureau of its authority over them. And, that’s why Community Choice brands CheckSmart and Cash Express have been generous contributors to sympathetic members of Congress, and why — with the help of Lewandowski and other mouthpieces — the industry is trying to get the Trump administration to remove the Bureau’s director (even if there is no legal basis for doing so) and replace him with someone who can be depended on to leave payday lenders alone.
Lewandowski may be too embarrassed for the moment to continue raising his voice on the industry’s behalf. We can hope that’s true, at any rate. With or without his assistance, however, the industry’s campaign will continue, and the Lewandowski episode has made the stakes very clear: Will the Consumer Bureau be allowed to go on doing the job it was created to do, standing up to the financial industry’s power and insisting on basic standards of transparency and fair play? Or will some of the financial world’s fastest and loosest operators find a way to undermine this agency and keep it from cracking down on their abuses at great long last?
— Jim Lardner

Wednesday, March 29, 2017

From CFED: Preserve Consumer Protections for Buyers of Manufactured Homes

Act Now to Preserve Consumer Protections for Buyers of Manufactured Homes!

A bill recently introduced in Congress would roll back some basic consumer protections for buyers of manufactured homes. That's right: the Preserving Access to Manufactured Housing Act, H.R. 1699, has been resurrected once again—putting vulnerable homebuyers at risk.
 

Take action now!

Tell your Representative to oppose the Preserving Access to Manufactured Housing Act. Here's how:
  • Call 202.224.3121 and ask to be connected to your Representative's office. If you don't know who your Representative is, find out here.
  • Once you're connected, here's what to say:
My name is [your name] from [your city and state], and I’m calling to request that you oppose H.R. 1699, the Preserving Access to Manufactured Housing Act. This bill would roll back critical consumer protections for buyers of manufactured homes and would once again expose vulnerable homebuyers to predatory, high-cost loans that put them at risk of losing their homes. 
 
Why does H.R. 1699 matter? Before the Dodd-Frank Act, chattel lending—which is used to finance most manufactured homes—was largely unregulated. Interest rates on chattel loans were high, as were default rates. Dodd-Frank gave the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) authority to regulate chattel loans; now, many of the same laws and regulations that govern mortgage lending also apply to chattel lending. The law already provides a few exemptions for manufactured home dealers and lenders, but H.R. 1699 would harm vulnerable individuals and families by stripping away needed protections.

Find out more about this bill and read the letter that CFED and consumers groups signed in opposition to the 2015 version.

Tuesday, February 14, 2017

Op-ed from New York Daily News: Cage the Sharks Circling Consumers

NEW YORK DAILY NEWS

Friday, February 10, 2017, 5:00 AM
Last Friday, hours before signing an executive order that put the Dodd-Frank financial reform law on the chopping block, President Trump name-checked Chase CEO Jamie Dimon. “There’s nobody better to tell me about Dodd-Frank than Jamie,” he said.
Translation: there’s no one better than Dimon to help gut Dodd-Frank. Chase has for years aggressively lobbied members of Congress to undermine financial reform. Now that Trump has packed his administration with Wall Street fat cats — including six Goldman Sachs alums — the table is set for a return to the pre-recession days when Wall Street wrote its own rules. We know how well that worked out.
Banks’ systematic peddling of toxic loans brought down the U.S. economy, wiping out an estimated $19.2 trillion in household wealth and 8.8 million jobs. Losses were especially devastating for people of color, whose neighborhoods were targeted by predatory mortgage lenders. Researchers at Brandeis University found half the collective wealth of African-Americans and more than two-thirds for Latinos stripped away.
Dodd-Frank was intended to protect people from discriminatory financial abuse and to prevent recurrent financial collapse. It imposed vital restrictions on risky derivatives, required that banks hold more capital to withstand shocks and authorized the government to liquidate the largest banks in the event of grave failures.
Perhaps most important, Dodd-Frank put a much-needed consumer cop on the beat. Since its inception in 2011, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau has returned $11.7 billion to 29 million consumers cheated by financial services companies.
Through enforcement actions, the agency has protected people from discriminatory lending, abusive debt collection, deceptive marketing, unfair billing and much more.
If anything, Dodd-Frank does not go far enough, especially when it comes to addressing systemic risk. As the financial reform bill moved through Congress, industry lobbyists worked to kill it line by line. The four too-big-to-fail banks that received the most bailout money from taxpayers are bigger now than they were before.
Stopping Trump’s economic agenda will mean standing up to powerful interests that have plenty to gain from decimating Dodd-Frank. New Yorkers must urge their members of Congress to oppose them, and Trump, at all costs.
But local action is also needed to ensure that these same powerful forces do not threaten New York’s consumer protections. While Trump takes a hatchet to federal financial reform, a handful of Albany legislators is poised to open the floodgates to predatory lending in New York.
Last month, East Harlem Assemblyman Robert Rodriguez reintroduced the Community Financial Services Access and Modernization Act. The bill is merely the check-cashing industry’s latest attempt to legalize usurious lending. It would allow New York check cashers to make high-cost loans, with no underwriting requirements, to mom-and-pop, family- and immigrant-owned businesses . Sound familiar?
In the state Senate, members of the Independent Democratic Conference, which caucuses with the Republicans, have advanced this and similar bills in the past.
If New York’s legislators are serious about ensuring access to affordable loans in underserved neighborhoods, they should support community development financial institutions, including low-income credit unions, which have a track record and mission of serving immigrants, small businesses, and communities that banks have long failed adequately to serve.
In 2007, New York established a fund for CDFIs, modeled after the federal CDFI Fund, which provides loans, grants, and investments in support of community development. New York has yet to allocate actual dollars to this state program. Given threats to the CFPB and to financial reform more generally, Gov. Cuomo should amend his proposed budget to breathe life into the state CDFI Fund, and send a clear signal that the check-casher bill is a non-starter.
Resisting Trump’s economic agenda will not be easy. Yes, it will mean fiercely defending Dodd-Frank and the CFPB. But it will also mean pushing New York’s electeds to support solutions grounded in economic and racial justice. Establishing a robust state CDFI Fund is an obvious place to start.
Morrison is the campaigns coordinator for New Economy Project.